Minnesota City's Toy Gun Ordinance A Paradox

by
posted on December 15, 2010
fargo.jpg

The ordinance, passed by a 5-2 margin during the City Council's regular meeting Dec. 13, did not extend a facsimile-gun carry ban to private residences, a provision Moorhead Police Chief David Ebinger wanted included. Chief Ebinger told council members he believed toy firearms pose potential problems at private parties and could also be used to intimidate during domestic altercations.

The proposed ordinance defines facsimile firearms as "any object not actually a firearm which is a replica of an actual firearm, which substantially duplicates an actual firearm, or which could reasonably be perceived to be an actual firearm."

Council member Mark Hintermeyer, who voted against the ordinance, suggested the measure not only violates the constitutional right to bear arms, but was also unnecessary because Minnesota law already prohibits the display of replica firearm with reckless disregard.

The Moorhead City Council, representing the city of 32,000 located across the Red River from Fargo, ND, is scheduled to revisit the ordinance on Jan. 10 for a final vote.

In addition to prohibiting toy guns in public places, Moorhead's proposed ordinance breaks new ground by specifically permitting fake firearms to be used for self-defense.

Really.

"This ordinance shall not restrict the use of a facsimile firearm for self defense of a person's residence or place of business."

While we can't say with ultimate certainty if it's unprecedented, it marks the first time we've heard of a law that encourages owning fake and non-functioning pistols for personal protection.

We'd wager the 77,000-plus Minnesota citizens who currently have concealed-carry permits prefer to own, train with and carry the real thing.

Latest

Kimber 2K11 Pistol
Kimber 2K11 Pistol

First Look: Kimber 2K11 Pistol

Available in two different versions chambered in either 9mm or .45 ACP

2024 Holiday Gift Guide: Gifts Over $200

Gifts for the gun owner in your life.

I Carry: Smith & Wesson M&P9 Shield Plus Carry Comp Pistol in a JM Custom Kydex Holster

In this week's episode of "I Carry," we have a Smith & Wesson M&P9 Shield Plus Carry Comp Performance Center pistol carried in a JM Custom Kydex Quick Ship AIWB Wing Claw 2.5 holster, with a Gideon Optics Judge green-dot sight.

First Look: Streamlight Stinger 2020 S Flashlight

Now available with a swappable, rechargeable battery pack.

First Look: Faxon ADJ Gas Block

Easily adjust your settings for suppressed to unsuppressed use.

Oneida County Sheriff’s Office Selects Night Fision Sights

The Optics Ready Stealth Series sights feature tritium vials that carry domed lenses optically engineered for superior visibility.

Interests



Get the best of Shooting Illustrated delivered to your inbox.